A few years ago I signed up for a Southwest card because my feed told me to. Free flights, no baggage fees, the whole influencer fantasy. I used it twice, missed the spend threshold that made any of it worthwhile, and ate a $99 annual fee for a card that sat untouched in my wallet.
Since then I’ve built up a stack I assumed was fine: anΒ Amex Gold, anΒ Amex Delta Reserve, aΒ Bank of America Travel RewardsΒ card. I never actually sat down and checked whether any of it was working the way I thought. So I did, card by card, for real, and I’m walking through exactly what I found so you can run the same check on your own wallet this weekend.
Card One: Amex Gold, $325/Year
My assumption going in: this is my everyday card, so it’s probably fine. What I actually found: it’s the right card for the job, but I’ve been sloppy about it.
It earns 4x at restaurants and US supermarkets, and it carries up to $424 a year in credits, Uber Cash, dining credits at places like Grubhub and Five Guys, Dunkin’, Resy, a Hotel Collection credit. I’m already using the Dunkin and Grubhub credits without thinking about it.
The Uber Cash credit is the one I’m actually skipping, since I’m more of an UberEats person and that spend already earns a credit on my Delta Reserve instead. Resy and the Hotel Collection credit are still an open question I need to check my statements for.
Verdict: keep it as my everyday card, but the real work is remembering to actually claim what it already offers.
Card Two: Delta Reserve, $650/Year
This is the one I was least sure about. I got it for the 50K bonus and the lounge access, and I’ve been telling myself the perks “come out to about $100 a month,” which is really just a guess I never checked.
The real number is better than my guess, but only if I use it correctly. It earns 3x on Delta purchases and 1x on everything else, which means it was never supposed to be a daily-spend card, and I only put general purchases on it at the start, to clear the minimum spend for the welcome bonus.
The credits run closer toΒ $560 a year across Resy, rideshare, and Delta Stays, plus a $2,500 MQD Headstart toward Medallion status and MQD Boost, which earns $1 of Medallion Qualification Dollars per $10 spent.Β Silver status starts at 5,000 MQDs, so the headstart alone gets me halfway there before I’ve flown anywhere.
Verdict: worth keeping, and I’m actually already using it the way it’s meant to be used. The work now is routing Delta-specific spend and the credit-eligible categories through it on purpose instead of by accident, starting with actually checking which restaurants are on Resy and remembering to pay with the Delta card when they are.
Card Three: Bank of America Travel Rewards
The easy one. I use this for 0% intro APR offers, not points, and that’s the correct use. Its 1.5x flat rate isn’t worth trying to optimize. Nothing to fix here, just confirming I’m not wasting energy trying to make this card do something it’s not built for.
The Cheat Sheet
Here’s the audit boiled down to what I’m actually supposed to do, screenshot-ready:
- GoldΒ β restaurants, US supermarkets, Dunkin, Grubhub. Default card for everything that isn’t Delta-related.
- Delta ReserveΒ β Delta flights and Delta Vacations, plus Resy restaurants and Delta Stays bookings when I check first. Nothing else touches this card.
- BofA Travel RewardsΒ β 0% APR offers only. Never for points.
- Missing from the stack:Β a flat 2% card (something like aΒ Citi Double Cash, orΒ Amex Blue Business PlusΒ if you run any business spend) for gas, subscriptions, and general online purchases. Nothing I currently carry earns well there, and that’s the one real hole.
What This Audit Actually Taught Me
Running through my own stack card by card surfaced a pattern I wasn’t expecting: tI had the right cards. I just hadn’t assigned them jobs.
Here’s the process I’m taking forward, and the one worth copying on your own wallet:
- Audit spend by category first, cards second.Β Pull three months of statements and sort by category: groceries, dining, travel, everything else. You can’t assign a card to a category you haven’t measured.
- Assign one card per category based on where it actually earns the most.Β Groceries and dining go to whichever card multiplies those hardest. Airline-specific spend goes to that airline’s card, and nowhere else.
- Run a fee-justification test once a year.Β Add up every credit and perk you genuinely used, not the ones printed on the card’s landing page. If that number clears the annual fee, keep the card. If it doesn’t, downgrade or cancel it.
- Redeem through transfer partners, never cash back.Β A point redeemed for a statement credit is worth about a cent. The same point transferred to an airline or hotel partner regularly runs 1.5 to 2 cents.
One more habit I picked up while researching this: price anything you’re about to book three ways before touching your points. The cash fare, the price inside your card’s travel portal, and the price after a transfer to a partner program.
Whichever number is worst, ignore it.Β Frequent flyer creators like Marina MogilkoΒ build entire strategies around this comparison, and it holds up whether you’re booking a $300 domestic flight or a business-class seat.
Pull up your own cards and ask the same questions I just asked mine. Happy points acquiring!

Thania (TA Content Mgr)